
Reducing the recent wave of violence in South Africa to a simple instance of xenophobia fails to get at the heart of the problem. Oftentimes the portrayal of the South African narrative in the West ignores the phenomenal achievement of a peaceful transition from totalitarian regime to democracy at the fin de siècle, and instead goes in for one rife with AIDS and violence. That template of the typical African basket case is well-worn but wide of the mark. And the recent violence between immigrant workers from around the continent hoping to make a better life for themselves and their economic competitors the native South Africans unfortunately plays into that narrative.
"Makwerekwere" is a highly derogatory word used by black South Africans to describe non-black South African migrants. These migrants are fleeing from places like South Africa's economically distressed neighbor, Zimbabwe, which had an astonishing inflation rate of 165,000 percent in February. Nigerian and Mozambican nationals have also been tagged with the contemptuous term. The writer Pius Adesanmi has written what he calls the Amakwerewere Syndrome, observing, "It reminds one of how the ancient Greeks referred to foreigners whose language they did not understand as the Barbaroi." This Us-versus-Them ideology comes from poverty, according to the acute social observer and comedian Chris Rock, whose South African comedy tour coincided with the attacks. From The Sowetan:
"The saddest thing about xenophobic violence is that it is a 'broke-on-broke crime,' US actor and comedian Chris Rock said yesterday.
"I don't believe in black-on-black violence because everybody robs and kills people...,' he said at a media briefing in Sandton, Johannesburg. 'It's not black-on-black but broke-on-broke when people rob each other.'"
Because these new immigrants often compete for jobs with the South African poor, the tensions can become acute. In 1997, for instance, local South African street traders clashed with foreign vendors. That was a classic episode of poor on poor violence fuelled by poverty. On the economic underpinnings of these tensions, Mandela Rhodes Scholar Boitumelo Magolego writes on the ThoughtLeader Blog:
"'I believe that pre-democracy, the black population by and large had a very similar and flat income profile (barring the few families which had shops, butcheries and medical practices); this homogeneity I believe played down issues of who had what, because by and large everyone was the same. Enter black diamonds and some families can now afford more than others. This I think creates subliminal pressure and frustration among those who are failing to access and reap the benefits of the country's liberalised economy. You may argue that this is not unique to South Africa; yes, nonetheless it is a contributing factor."
[image: AP/WorldWide Photo]