Who Cares? Apathy Across America

munch.scream2.jpgLast Thursday, I was running to catch a train, and I slipped at the top of an 18-step flight of stairs, causing my feet to fly backwards as my upper body lurched forward, like a cartoon. The next thing I knew, I was sliding and bumping down the stairs, head-first, until I reached the bottom, where I laid in shock for several seconds and tried to determine if I'd cracked my head open or knocked out any teeth. My head and shoulders were on the subway platform, my legs still splayed out on the metal-edged stairs.


Once I'd oriented myself and confirmed that my head was OK, I opened my eyes to an upside-down subway platform with numerous people on it. No one said or did a thing.


Still in shock, I yelled out, "Oh, I'm fine! Thanks everyone for asking!" I must have looked ridiculous, but I know that I did not look drunk or homeless: It was the middle of the afternoon and I was wearing a nice sport coat and carrying a leather briefcase.


But what if I had been drunk or homeless? People would have stepped over and ignored me just as quickly, and that would have been deemed acceptable (if unethical). Depending on the day, I would do the same -- I certainly have in the past -- and I doubt that many of us can say different. Who stops to help every person they see who obviously needs it? The fact that I was neither drunk nor homeless only underscored a sad fact of public life: We're all on our own, even those of us who can't be written off, however unjustly, as social pariahs.


That afternoon, I posted my fall as a Facebook status update and included the bit about no one helping me. Within hours, I'd received several accounts of similar misfortune, met with equal apathy from bystanders. One friend said he did knock out his front teeth in such a subway fall, and no one said a word.


But contrary to what my parents back in Illinois may think, apathy is not a "New York thing." My sister-in-law posted a comment to my update about the time she saw an elderly woman fall across the street, and she was the first person to reach her -- not the closest. That was in a small town in Wisconsin.


Another friend wrote that when she was pregnant with her second child, she accidentally locked her toddler daughter in the car on a busy street in Providence, Rhode Island. "I was hysterical and screaming like a lunatic through the window at her to sit forward and pull up the door lock," she wrote. "At least 15 people passed and didn't help. I was a crazy, hugely pregnant maniac. Oh, by the way, I was parked in front of a church..."


The problem of apathy in America generally focuses on politics and social justice. Many Americans simply don't involve themselves with the issues that threaten to hurt or weaken society, despite being part of that society themselves. People litter, fail to vote, ignore others in need. But something happens when you experience apathy first-hand: you wake up a bit.


The day after my fall, I was walking up the stairs of another subway station when a man beside me tripped and fell forward. I immediately asked if he was OK, which clearly took him by surprise. A few days earlier, I must admit, I can't say I'd have bothered. Fortunately, he was fine.


If you'd like to learn from my lesson and help those less fortunate that yourself (without falling down the stairs first) visit VolunteerMatch, presented by Kenneth Cole.


[Image: Edvard Munch's "The Scream"]

Comments (2)

It's regrettable that this happened, but as your sister-in-law points out, it's not limited to the big city. Popular media bludgeons us daily with stories of folks who stopped to help someone on a country road and ended up being chased around by some fellow in a hockey mask with a chainsaw(no... that was the movie) but you get the idea. Stories about people doing decent things don't sell.
We seem to be living in a time of anomie and all those things that we have taken for granted are either eroding or missing.
Case in point are all the things your parents' generation grew up "knowing" that no longer apply:
- America is the richest, most generous, most peace loving country in the world
- America will defend freedom wherever necessary, but we never start wars... we finish them.
- We all watch out for each other
- We take the biblical story of the good samaritan seriously
- We believe in hard work and honesty
- All one has to do is approach the world with a sense of justice and the world will be a just place...

Well, you get the idea. These things haven't gone away overnight. They have eroded gradually over the last few decades. (with a big push in the '80's from St. Ronnie [patron saint of financial pillagers] and a slash at personal responsibility and integrity from wierd Uncle Bill. The final nail was the loss of standing in the world by America courtesy of the shrub)
Will it change back? I doubt it. Today's future voters are a cynical lot and little is likely to change.
All this to say, sadly, you're right. But in the end all we can do is make what little encroachments we can to encourage people to pass on the good and overcome the bad.
Have a good Christmas.
mike

I'm so sorry you fell. Having been a New Yorker for almost 11 years (born in the Midwest, now live in Paris) I can 100% guarantee you that I would have stopped to help you. So would everyone in my family. My brother was once visiting and a man slipped on the platform as he boarded the train. We and everyone on the train immediately ran to help him. Fortunately, he was more embarrassed than hurt.

I will tell you one NYC that might make it feel better. I had just gone shopping in my office building - buying myself some much-needed new work clothes to the tune of about $500. I being a good subway rider put the bag under my seat. When I got off at my stop, I realized just as the doors were closing that I had not grabbed my bag.

I was so upset and the MTA person just said, "too bad."

Later that evening the credit department of the store called. A young woman had been sitting next to me on the train and realized I had left my bag. She took it home, checked for the receipt, and called the store's 800 number.

I went to to her office the next day to picked up my things. I also gave her $100 as a reward.

She could have just as easily returned every item and bought things for herself. I always remember that story and know that there are good and bad people everywhere. I thought NYCers in general (except those being paid in service positions) were as friendly as anyone in the country.

Whatever we seek, we will find. If you think our country is apathetic and unhelpful, that's what you'll experience. Try for one week to think of New Yorkers as helpful, open, and caring. Then write another post - I bet your experience will be different and I can't wait to read it!

Elisabeth

Leave a comment